Call for input for thematic report to the 60th session of the Human Rights Council
Issued by
Special Procedures
Deadline
31 March 2025
Issued by
Special Procedures
Deadline
31 March 2025
There is a growing divide between the Global North and South across all domains, with economic disparities, both international and domestic. Widening inequalities among and within states highlight the profound inequities embedded in the current global financial architecture. Yet major international financial institutions remain “for most purposes” a “human rights-free zone”, as former Special Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty Philip Alston described in a report to the General Assembly (para. 68, A/70/274-2015). At its core, this divide reflects a clash of interests rather than a battle of ideas or arguments. Resolving these conflicts rationally is becoming increasingly challenging, as the discourse surrounding them has bifurcated into two parallel monologues: on the one hand, a seemingly apolitical, technocratic narrative that avoids addressing the root causes of inequalities and on the other, a polemical, often ideological critique, marked by denunciations but lacking concrete, actionable proposals.
There is a critical need to address normative disparities between the Global North and South, which impact key areas such as democracy and human rights (SDG 16: Peace, Justice, and Strong Institutions), environmental sustainability (SDGs 13, 14, 15) and social equity (SDGs 5, 10) using measurable indices of regulatory delivery. Regulatory delivery is a dynamic approach to governance that looks beyond conventional policy frameworks, prioritizing the practical implementation and enforcement of norms in real-world contexts with the view of achieving meaningful societal outcomes. Through tools like outcome measurement, risk-based prioritization, and tailored interventions, it redefines effective regulation by providing a pragmatic foundation for adaptable, globally benchmarked frameworks.
In order to avoid the pitfalls of abstract "good governance" conditionality and adopt a new paradigm for establishing a sustainable human rights economy, oriented to the full realization of economic and social rights, the evaluation should go beyond measuring economic growth and critically assess the impact of international and transnational actors, such as International Financial Institutions (IFIs) and multinational corporations (MNCs), on economic and social rights. Building on this novel outlook, the proposed UN Global Regulatory Delivery Index (GRDI) will offer a key mechanism that will shed light and help to address global disparities in regulatory effectiveness and enforcement, with a view of meeting the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), the objectives of the Global Digital Compact (GDC) as well as those of the UN Pact for the Future (PfP).
By identifying and measuring the gaps in how regulations and norms protect rights, promote equity and foster sustainability as normative or regulatory inequities, the GRDI can illuminate the barriers disproportionately affecting vulnerable populations, especially in the Global South. As a catalyst for advancing a human rights economy, the GRDI aligns the goal of normative convergence with the need to invest in economic, social, and cultural rights while addressing systemic barriers to equality and justice. (PfP Action 7) This focus is critical in fostering governance systems that empower rather than exclude. By prioritizing human rights, social equity, and sustainability, the GRDI creates a transformative pathway for governments and institutions to harmonize regulations with the goals of inclusivity and development. (PfP Action 12).
Envisioned as a blueprint for enhancing the normative convergence between North and South, the GRDI seeks to bridge the divides, fostering a more democratic and equitable international order. (PfP Action 38). To these ends, it aims to establish itself as a global benchmark for regulatory delivery, rooted in the principles of accountability, transparency, and inclusiveness. (PfP, Action 43) It aims to evaluate and enhance regulatory practices globally, focusing on regions disproportionately affected by normative disparities. Structured around three critical dimensions, namely democracy and human rights, environmental sustainability and social equity. Through clear, objective standards, it will identify systemic shortcomings, highlight strengths, and promote equitable regulatory practices worldwide (PfP Action 53), creating a roadmap for inclusive growth and sustainable development.