Skip to main content
Report

Call for input: Externalization of migration governance:-new trends and specific aspects

Issued by

Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants

Published

14 May 2026

Report

Issued by Special Procedures

Subject

Migrants

Symbol Number

A/HRC/62/35

Background

In his report on Externalization of migration governance and its effect on the human rights of migrants (A/80/302), the Special Rapporteur on the rights of migrants warned about the growing practice of outsourcing migration governance, whereby destination States transfer migration control, asylum processing and readmission functions to third countries. As these measures shift responsibility for migration governance, they create serious risks of human rights violations, especially in contexts where receiving States lack the capacity or willingness to ensure protection. Among the rights most affected are the right to leave any country, the prohibition of refoulement, the prohibition of collective expulsions, access to due process and effective remedies, as well as the prohibition of arbitrary detention, torture, inhuman treatment, enforced disappearance and racial discrimination. In addition, migrants subjected to these practices often face precarious conditions that compromise their economic, social and cultural rights.

The report also highlighted the opacity with which many of these agreements are negotiated and implemented, characterised by a lack of parliamentary oversight and independent accountability mechanisms. The involvement of multiple state and non-state actors further complicates the attribution of legal responsibility. The Rapporteur recalled that states cannot evade their international obligations by delegating migration control to third parties, and that violations can be attributable to both outsourcing states and transit or receiving states.

Among his recommendations, the Rapporteur urged States to end agreements that prevent the arrival of migrants, transfer asylum processing outside their borders, or allow readmissions to unsafe third countries, which shift responsibility for migration governance to third States and lead to human rights violations. As long as these arrangements remain in place, he called for binding legal safeguards, prior and independent human rights impact assessments, and accessible complaint and redress mechanisms. He also emphasised the need to strengthen transparency by publishing all agreements, ensuring civil society participation in their design and monitoring, and suspending any cooperation that finances violations. The central message is clear: migration governance must be based on unrestricted respect for human rights, good faith and shared responsibility among States.

Given the scale and complexity of externalization, the emergence of new agreements, and the persistent risk of serious human rights violations, the Special Rapporteur has decided to continue focusing on externalization and monitor the developments of the increasing number of so-called “cooperation agreements” as well as their implementation, and assess their impact on the human rights of migrants. He will present the findings of this work in his next report to the Human Rights Council in June 2026.

Objectives

Building on his report to the 80th session of the General Assembly (A/80/302), the forthcoming report will outline, based on the monitoring, the recent externalization agreements and measures and provide an analysis of the following aspects of externalization:

  • Legislative developments in both externalizing and third States aimed at accommodating externalization measures;
  • Rationale of third States to adhere to externalization policies and enter into bilateral agreements;
  • Return hubs and understanding of “safe countries”
  • Externalization as a measure to reducing migration towards destination countries and consequences for migration patterns, smuggling and trafficking in persons;
  • Human rights impact assessments, due diligence processes, monitoring and oversight mechanisms as measures to foster transparency;
  • Impact on children and families on the move;
  • Gendered impacts and intersectional dimensions;
  • Use of digital technologies in externalization and threats to human rights of migrants;
  • Role and responsibility of the private sector in externalization practices.
Key questions and types of input/comments sought

To develop a comprehensive report, the Special Rapporteur welcomes input from a broad range of stakeholders and invites contributions that address the following key questions and areas of inquiry:

1. Recent trends and human rights violations

Please share information on externalization agreements or arrangements adopted since spring 2025, including new or emerging forms of externalized migration governance.

What are recent examples of human rights violations occurring in the context of externalization?

2. Laws and the responsibility vacuum

What legislative provisions enable or facilitate externalization measures in both externalizing States (e.g. the use of the safe third country concept) and third States (e.g. legislation criminalizing irregular migration or exit from the country)?

Are you aware of examples where externalization measures have resulted in a dilution of responsibility or a legal void regarding the protection of migrants?

3. Motivations and impact on third States

What measures are used by externalizing States to encourage third States to cooperate on migration management? Please provide detailed information on the instruments, and if available, indicate which other stakeholders are involved in the process.

In addition to specific measures, kindly indicate any other motivation for third States, including political or strategic, to engage in externalization partnerships?

What are the effects of externalization measures on third States and their populations, including on governance, human rights, and social cohesion?

Has externalization been effective in reducing migration towards externalizing States? What are the consequences of these measures for migration patterns, smuggling, and trafficking in persons?

5. Transparency

Please share examples of human rights impact assessments, due diligence processes, and monitoring or oversight mechanisms that aim to promote transparency and accountability in externalization policies.

6. Technology and private actors

In what ways is technology—including specific digital tools, surveillance systems, or data-sharing mechanisms—used to facilitate or support externalization measures? How does the use of technology contribute to or exacerbate risks of human rights violations against migrants, and to what extent are there avenues for justice and redress? How is data protection ensured in the context of such technologies?

What is the role of private companies in the design, financing, or implementation of externalization measures, and what accountability and redress mechanisms exist?

7. Persons in vulnerable situations and intersectional discrimination

What specific impacts do externalization measures have on children on the move and families? Please highlight protection gaps, including for unaccompanied or separated children.

What are the gender-based violence (GBV) risks at different stages of externalization (e.g. interception, detention, transfer, return)? What protection gaps exist for women, girls, and LGBTQI+ persons, and what measures should be taken to prevent, investigate, and respond to GBV?

How is racial and intersectional discrimination embedded in externalization? How does the intersection of race, nationality, gender, and socioeconomic status increase the exposure of migrants to harm and human rights violations in this context?

How inputs will be used?

All submissions will be posted on the mandate’s website. Should you wish to maintain confidentiality of your submission, kindly clearly indicate it at the moment of submission.

For more on information on the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants, please click here.

Inputs Received
Inputs Received
States

Algeria

Argentina

Azerbaijan

Belarus

Brazil

Colombia

Dominican Republic

Ecuador

Greece

Montenegro

NHRIs

Australian Human Rights Commission

Defensoría del Pueblo de Colombia

UN entities

UN Women

UNICEF

Regional mechanism

Council of Europe

Council of Europe Anti-discrimination Department

CSOs

Advocates for Human Rights: annex-1 | annex-2

Ágora

Associazione Comunità Papa Giovanni XXIII (APG23)

AsyLex

Asylum Seeker Resource Centre (ASRC)

Brot für die Welt

Centre for Peace Studies; AsyLex

Centro de Derechos Humanos de la Universidad Católica Andrés Bello (CDH UCAB) et al.

CHIRLA México-Coalición Pro Derechos Humanos del Inmigrante A.C.

Cimde and CCFD-Terre Solidaire

EuroMed Rights et al.

European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE)

Francesco Pasetti; Francesca Lupi

Fundación Scalabriniana; Red CLAMOR; Red Franciscana para Migrantes Honduras

GEM Tigray (Gender Empowerment Movement Tigray)

Global Detention Project

Human Rights Advocates and partners

Human Rights First

Human Rights Watch

Humans for Rights Network

International Detention Coalition

Justice in Motion

Loujna-Tounkaranké and partners

Maat for Peace, Development, and Human Rights

Movimiento por la Paz, el Desarme y la Libertad (MPDL)

Novact; Centro Irídia; Solidary Wheels; Fúndec; No Name Kitchen

Quaker United Nations Office

Red Acoge

Refugee Council of Australia

The Advocates for Human Rights

The Advocates for Human Rights and The Binger Center for New Americans

The Border Violence Monitoring Network and partners

TuczapskiTomasz

Women in Migration Network (WIMN)

World Organisation Against Torture (OMCT) and the Libyan Anti-torture Network (LAN)

Academia

Alejandro Andino

Anna Talbot

Axana Soltan

Baptiste Jouzier

Center for International Human Rights, John Jay College of Criminal Justice - City University of New York

Elif Mendos Kuşkonmaz; Esin Küçük

Ilse Derluyn

Jeanne Tesson

Jonathan Lam

Kathryn Allinson

Madeline Gleeson

Maria-Ecaterina Nistor

Marie-Laure Basilien-Gainche

Professor Paul James Cardwell

University of Bristol Human Rights Implementation Centre