Background
For almost a century, the international community has not succeeded in defining “terrorism”, and negotiations remain stalled on the UN draft comprehensive convention against international terrorism, after discussions commenced in 2001. The Security Council required all States to criminalize terrorist acts in domestic law and take other measures to prevent and suppress terrorism under Security Council resolution 1373 (2001), with further measures required under subsequent resolutions, but did not impose a binding definition of terrorism. For two decades the Special Rapporteur and other human rights bodies have frequently identified vague and overbroad definitions of terrorism in national laws and the instruments of regional organisations, as well as in the normative practice and technical activities of the United Nations. Such definitions are prone to abuse and often lead to violations of fundamental human rights, including against members of civil society. Efforts to build consensus on definition remain essential to mitigate one of the most prevalent sources globally of human rights violations in counter-terrorism.
Objectives
The Special Rapporteur’s report aims to identify a best practice international definition of terrorism that is consistent with international law, including international human rights law, international humanitarian law and international refugee law. Such definition will revise and update the 2010 model definition of the Special Rapporteur (A/HRC/16/51, paras. 26-28). The report also aims to address the potential need for definition of “terrorist organisation”, and whether “violent extremism” is capable of adequate definition and the implications for whether and how this concept should be used.
Key questions and types of input/comments sought
The Special Rapporteur is particularly interested in the following issues:
- What risks to human rights are presented by definition(s) of terrorism, violent extremism and extremism? What types of physical acts and “specific intent” elements should be avoided?
- What physical conduct elements (actus reus) should define terrorism?
- Should terrorism be limited to intentionally causing death or serious personal injury or hostage taking? Does personal injury in this context cover mental or psychological harm where there is no physical injury? Should the definition identify specific criminal acts that cause death/injury/hostage taking, or simply refer to any criminal act that intentionally causes such harm?
- Should the definition also include reference to acts “endangering” or creating serious risks to life, health or public safety?
- Should the definition include damage or destruction to property (public and private) without intentionally causing death or injury? If so, (i) what types of property should be included and (ii) what thresholds of damage, destruction or other consequences (e.g. major economic loss) should be required?
- Should acts against critical infrastructure be included, and if so, how? Should “critical infrastructure” be defined, and if so, how?
- Should terrorism cover acts against financial and electronic systems? If so, what thresholds of harm should be required?
- Should international law more specifically define the mental element (mens rea) of terrorism, or should this be left to national jurisdictions?
- What is the scope of “intent” (and knowledge) in the context of terrorism? Should it differ between different terrorism offences?
- Should the definition require that the harmful outcome always be deliberate (i.e. intentional death or injury), or is it sufficient if the outcome would occur in the ordinary course of events (i.e., an intentional act would be highly certain to cause death/injury, even if death/injury was not specifically intended)?
- What “specific intent” elements should define terrorism?
- e.g., provoke a state of terror in the general public or in a group of persons or particular persons? e.g. (seriously) intimidate the public?
- Is it unhelpfully duplicative to refer to both a state of terror and intimidating the public as alternatives in the same definition?
- Does reference to a “group of persons” or the “general public” adequately cover entities such as, for example, civil society / non-governmental organisations, corporations, trade unions, religious associations and so on, or should such entities be specifically mentioned as potential targets?
- e.g., (unduly) compel a government or international organization to do or refrain from doing something?
- Should any other specific intent element be included?
- Should the definition additionally require that the act be committed with one or more of the following purposes: (i) political (see especially the 1994 General Assembly Declaration on Measures to Eliminate International Terrorism), (ii) ideological, (iii) philosophical, (iv) religious or (v) racial?
- Should such purpose be the exclusive or predominant purpose, a substantial or significant purpose, or merely one of any number of possibly mixed purposes?
- Do each of these purposes require further definition or interpretive guidance as to their scope, or can they be left to judicial interpretation over time?
- Would such purposes help to distinguish terrorism from profit-oriented organised crime (including cartels and gangs), which is subject to the separate legal framework of the UN Convention against Transnational Organised Crime? Should the definition of terrorism include organised crime, and if so, how and to what extent?
- Should the definition of terrorism contain any of the following exceptions (and if so, subject to what qualifications):
- Acts of protest which do not intentionally cause death, serious injury or hostage taking;
- The provision of humanitarian assistance;
- The activities of armed forces in armed conflict governed by [in conformity with] international humanitarian law;
- The activities of State military forces in the exercise of their official duties (i.e., in peacetime);
- The struggle for self-determination / national liberation in accordance with international law;
- Acts in defence of human rights.
- How should the definition of terrorism address “State terrorism”? Consider:
- The possible exclusion of armed forces in armed conflict;
- The possible exclusion of State military forces in peacetime;
- The functional immunities of State officials and any exceptions;
- How the definition should apply in a criminal law context compared with under the law of State responsibility.
- Is the definition in the UN Draft Comprehensive Counter-Terrorism Convention, under negotiation since 2001, adequate? What elements should be improved? How should the current impasse over exceptions (regarding armed forces and State military activities) be bridged?
- Should international law define the meaning of “terrorist organisation” for the purpose of the international or national listing or designation of such organisations (e.g. to impose sanctions or trigger additional criminal law liabilities)? If so, what additional elements (beyond the underlying definition of “terrorism”) are necessary to define “organisation” and to articulate the link between terrorism and the organisation?
- Should international law define “violent extremism” and “extremism”, or are these incapable of adequate legal definition in a manner that is consistent with international human rights law?
How inputs will be used?
Submissions will be made public on the website of the Special Rapporteur, unless confidentiality is requested. Please specify in the subject line if you prefer it remains confidential.