Skip to main content
Report

Call for inputs: Externalization of Migration and the Impact on the Human Rights of Migrants

Issued by

Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants

Published

04 August 2025

presented to

General Assembly - eightieth session

Report

Issued by Special Procedures

Subject

Migrants

Symbol Number

A/80/302

Background

In recent years, externalisation has become a defining feature of migration, asylum, and border policies, particularly among high-income destination countries. This umbrella term refers to measures designed to prevent migration, carry out administrative processes beyond national borders, and facilitate return through the involvement of third countries. The concept of "externalisation" can thus be broadly understood as “the process of shifting functions that are normally undertaken by a State within its own territory so that they take place, in part or in whole, outside its territory.” Such practices may expose individuals to situations in which their human rights are not protected.

Externalisation measures are typically based on bilateral or multilateral agreements or informal arrangements, and often involve funding, equipping and training offered to strengthen migration management capacities in cooperating States. Common externalisation strategies include preventing departure or transit through third countries by criminalising “irregular” exit or enhancing border control measures. Other measures include joint interceptions and pull-backs, as well as the transfer of asylum processing to third countries, including offshore detention, and the establishment of “return hubs.” Another set of measures relates to readmission cooperation, whereby countries designated as “safe” are expected to accept the return of migrants who transited their territory en route to a destination country. The list is not exhaustive, as externalisation practices are diverse and frequently obscured by the opacity that characterises many such arrangements.

Externalisation often involves development aid or technical cooperation aimed at enhancing migration management and border control capacity in third countries. These arrangements can instrumentalise development cooperation, aligning it with migration control objectives. Such arrangements often pressure cooperating States to act as gatekeepers or to implement migration and asylum procedures, frequently without adequate safeguards or resources to ensure compliance with human rights standards, despite migration control not necessarily being among their policy priorities.

A defining feature of externalisation is its lack of transparency. While some readmission agreements are publicly available, their implementation often remains opaque. Informal arrangements are frequently not accessible to the public at all. Although certain agreements provide for monitoring mechanisms, it is often unclear how these are operationalised and by whom. Transparency is further undermined by the involvement of non-State actors, including intergovernmental or international organisations and private companies, in the implementation of some measures. The use of border and surveillance technologies and AI compounds this opacity, making it even more difficult to ensure accountability and oversight.

The core objective of externalisation, to keep migrants away from destination countries, combined with a lack of transparency, oversight, and effective monitoring, entails significant risks of leaving people outside the protective scope of international human rights law. Frequently, human rights protections in cooperating States are weaker than those in externalising States. Moreover, individuals subject to these practices may lack access to regular migration status or asylum procedures and may face risks of discrimination in the cooperating State. The externalisation measures may result in violations of several human rights, including the right to leave any country, including one’s own; the prohibition of torture and ill-treatment; the principle of non-refoulement; the prohibition of collective expulsion; the right to due process; the prohibition of arbitrary detention; the right to life; and the principle of non-discrimination. When such violations occur, attributing responsibility is challenging due to the involvement of multiple States and non-State actors, as well as the difficulty of establishing extraterritorial jurisdiction.

Specific externalisation measures have been addressed by the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants (hereafter Special Rapporteur) and other UN experts and bodies. For instance, the Special Rapporteur noted with concern policy of relocating certain asylum seekers to third countries posing a real risk of refoulement. He also expressed concern about its impact on the right to an effective remedy to challenge such countries’ designations as safe third countries and to ensure protection against refoulement. On the migration bilateral agreements, the Special Rapporteur, expressed concern at the risk of refoulement, inadequate procedural guarantees and automatic detention after transfer.. For its part, the Human Rights Committee reaffirmed that States remain responsible under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights for the treatment of individuals detained in offshore processing facilities, provided they exercise effective control over those operations. More broadly, the previous Special Rapporteur urged States to suspend, cancel and revoke, as necessary, bilateral and multilateral return and readmission agreements, including those based on the safe third country concept, which risk violating the prohibition of collective expulsion and the principle of non-refoulement.

This report seeks to build upon the existing body of recommendations on specific measures and offer a comprehensive, cross-cutting assessment of externalization practices through the lens of human rights protection, transparency, accountability, and monitoring. By shedding light on the human rights risks associated with externalisation practices and the obstacles to accountability in externalised migration policies, this report aims to clarify key questions related to State jurisdiction, responsibility, and the extraterritorial application of human rights.

Objectives

Specifically, the report aims to achieve the following objectives:

  • To shed light on externalisation measures across the world;
  • To examine how externalization measures impact the human rights of migrants and assess State responsibility for resulting violations, including those arising from specific extraterritorial measures, or actions/complicity of States;
  • To identify to what extent externalization measures, create or exacerbate situations of vulnerability;
  • To contribute to the understanding of the relationship between externalisation, corresponding human rights violations and jurisdiction/responsibility for both States and non-State actors;
  • To assess the impact of externalisation on cooperating States and their regions;
  • To evaluate the transparency of externalisation arrangements, including their public accessibility, access to information, and the use of human rights impact assessments;
  • To identify the financial costs of externalisation measures and the funding sources used to support them, including use of funding classified as official development assistance for migration-related projects;
  • To analyse how externalisation measures are monitored, including the involvement of independent bodies and parliaments, the funding of monitoring activities, and the publication of monitoring outcomes;
  • To identify the non-State actors involved in designing and implementing externalisation measures and their respective roles;
  • To scrutinise the use of technologies in supporting externalisation efforts, including risks associated with surveillance and data collection;
  • To provide recommendations aimed at enhancing human rights protection, transparency, monitoring, accountability and responsibility for human rights abuses in the context of externalisation.
Key questions and types of input/comments sought

To develop a comprehensive and well-informed report, the Special Rapporteur welcomes inputs from a broad range of stakeholders and invites contributions that address the following key questions and areas of inquiry:

  1. Examples of externalisation measures

    Please share examples of externalisation policies or measures, including prevention of leaving, push back or pull back practices, interdiction at sea, joint border controls or interceptions, readmission arrangements, safe country concepts, third country and offshore processing, extraterritorial detention/reception centres (including “return hubs”).

    If available, please provide information in relation to these examples on the following: a) What is the (legal) basis for these measures, specifically, are they based on formal or informal agreements?; b) Which entities are responsible for negotiating, concluding and implementing these arrangements (executives/parliaments/agencies e.g. border agencies, police forces or equivalent)?; c) To what extent are these measures practical to implement in practice?

  2. Transparency and monitoring

    a) Is the legal basis for externalisation measures (such as Memoranda of Understanding) publicly available?; b) Is the information on externalisation measures (including implementing measures and technical cooperation) made available under freedom of information/access to documents laws, when requested?; c) What monitoring mechanisms are foreseen and how do they function in practice?; d) Are human rights impact assessments carried out, especially prior to agreement, and if so, what are their modalities, including findings being public?; e) Are there complaint mechanisms in place?

  3. Cooperating States

    a) How do cooperating States benefit from these arrangements?; b) What is offered in exchange for cooperation; c) Are the arrangements subject to democratic scrutiny and oversight (e.g. by parliamentary committees)?; d) Are the measures made public and/or announced by the authorities in cooperating States?; e) Did the agreements trigger changes in national laws or policies?

  4. Non-State actors

    a) What is the role of non-State entities in the development and implementation of externalisation measures? These entities may include international/regional/intergovernmental organisations, private companies (including Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) and technology companies), armed groups, or NGOs; b) What are the implications of the involvement of non-State entities with regard to transparency, accountability, and human rights protections?

  5. Use of technology

    a) In what ways is technology, including specific tools or systems, employed to facilitate or support externalisation measures?; b) If technology enabling the collection and processing of personal data is provided to or acquired by cooperating States, where is that data stored and by whom?; c) In which ways does the use of technology contribute to or exacerbate the risk of violations of the human rights of migrants and to what extent are there avenues for justice?

  6. Human rights implications

    a) What is the (practical and/or legal) situation of individuals once they are transferred or taken to the cooperating States, irrespective of their nationality and migration status?; b) What human rights risks arise in connection with specific externalisation measures or particular phases of their implementation—such as prevention of departure, interception, detention, or return/transfer?; c) To what extent do migrants and their families have access to justice for human rights violations that occurred as a result of externalisation practices throughout their migration journey?

  7. Responsibility and jurisdiction

a) How can the responsibility of the externalising State be established in cases of human rights violations? b) What jurisdictional approaches may be invoked to assess the extraterritorial application of human rights obligations in the context of externalisation practices involving migrants?; c) Please provide examples of rulings by international or national courts related to externalisation measures, including addressing migrants who have not yet reached the territory of destination countries.

How inputs will be used?

All submissions will be posted on the mandate’s website. Should you wish to maintain confidentiality of your submission, kindly clearly indicate it at the moment of submission.

For more on information on the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants, please click here.

Inputs Received
Inputs Received
States

Mexico

NHRIs

Australian Human Rights Commission

UN entities

UNHCR

Regional Organisation

European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA): annex | annex-1 | annex-2 | annex-3 | annex-4 | annex-5

ODIHR

CSOs

Access Now and BVMN

Al Otro Lado

American Friends Service Committee, CELS, Centro por la Justicia y el Derecho Internacional, Franciscans International, Servicio Jesuita para Migrantes-Costa Rica, RFM, RFM-Panama, Dejusticia

Amnesty International

ASGI

AsyLex

Black Alliance for Just Immigration

Border Violence Monitoring Network

Brot für die Welt

Calais Food Collectives

CARITAS Paris

CEJIL

CELS

COFUND

Colectivo de Monitoreo Frontera Sur

Colour of Poverty - Colour of Change; BLAC, Chinese Canadian National Council for Social Justice, OCASI, South Asian Legal Clinic of Ontario

Corporación Espacios de Mujer

Dejusticia, iLIT, CESI

EMERGENCY

Encuentros, SJM Perú, SJM Chile & RJM-LAC

EuroMed Rights

Fenix Humanitarian Legal Aid

Fórum Interncional Fronteiras Cruzadas – Fontié ki Kwaze

Fundación Democracia Internacional

GDP

Global Strategic Litigation Council

Greek Council for Refugees

Human Rights First

Human Rights Law Centre

International Detention Coalition

International Rescue Committee Italy

IRAP

Jesuit Refugee Service UK

Joint submission by HIAS, Oxfam, the Global Strategic Litigation Council, the National Network for Immigrant and Human Rights, Hope Border Institute, and Americans for Immigrant Justice

La Cima: input | annex-2 | annex-1

Last Rights, Methoria

Lebanese Center for Human Rights

Maat for Peace, Development and Human Rights Association

MSF: input-1 | input-2

No Name Kitchen

Novact, Centro Irídia, Solidary Wheels, Fündec, No Name Kitchen

OMCT, LAN

Oxfam

PICUM

por Causa

Programa de Asuntos Migratorios Universidad Iberoamericana Ciudad de México y la Red Jesuita con Migrantes Latinoamérica y el Caribe

Project Play France

Red Jesuita con Migrantes de Centroamérica y Norteamérica

Refugees Platform Egypt

SOS Humanity

Statewatch

Terre Solidaire: input | annex

The Center for Victims of Torture

TIME: input-1 | input-2 | input-3

Union des Avocat Europeens

UpRights & StraLi

Utopia 56

Vatra

Academia and experts

Alice Riccardi and Laura Di Gianfrancesco -Roma Tre University

Anna Maria Puigderrajols Triadó

Ayse Yildiz

Boston University School of Law

Brigit Shumi

Center for Gender & Refugee Studies: input | annex-1 | annex-2 | annex-3 | annex-4

Center on Privacy and Technology- George Town University

Clínica Jurídica de Movilidad Humana Transfronteriza

EmilieMcDonnell

Francesca Lupi

Gerardo Dasyel Mendoza Capetillo - Graduate Institute

Giulia Raimondo & Joyce De Coninck

Imen Khemakhem

Ishita Paul

Jeanne Tesson: input | annex-2 | annex-1

Kaldor Centre for International Refugee Law: input-1 | input-2 | input-3 | annex-2 | annex-1

Lena Riemer

Maria O’Sullivan- Deakin University

Marzia Ferraro

Paul Odhiambo

Programa de Asuntos Migratorios

Rizlaine Stitou Lheureux

Rossella Pulvirenti & Kay Lalor

Rüdiger Dossow

Virginia Blanca Vagelli