Global population ageing is transforming societies at an unprecedented pace. Increasing numbers of older persons live with frailty, chronic illness, disability, cognitive impairment, or growing reliance on others for support in daily life and care. Yet dependency is still too often perceived through the lenses of decline, burden, incapacity, or loss of social value. As a result, situations of dependency may become associated with invisibility, paternalism, exclusion, institutionalization, neglect, coercion, or diminished participation in family, community and public life.
At the centre of this report is a fundamental question: what happens to a person’s dignity, autonomy and rights when they become dependent on others? This report will present a vision of ageing in which situations of dependency do not necessarily lead to diminished autonomy, social exclusion, or erosion of human dignity. Dependency must not become a condition of diminished humanity, reduced personhood, or weakened entitlement to human rights.
Older persons living in situations of dependency continue to express preferences, sustain relationships, participate in social life, contribute to their communities, and exercise different forms of autonomy and agency. Dependency does not diminish human dignity, equal personhood, or entitlement to the full enjoyment of human rights.
The report will examine how human rights frameworks, public policies, healthcare systems, long-term care arrangements, and social practices address situations of dependency in older age. It will explore how autonomy, dignity, participation and
inclusion can be preserved and strengthened in contexts of physical frailty, disability, cognitive vulnerability, or increasing reliance on care and support.
Particular attention will be given to the following:
- relational autonomy and supported decision-making;
- ageism, paternalism and infantilization;
- institutionalization and community inclusion;
- access to healthcare, rehabilitation and long-term care;
- informal caregiving and family support;
- participation in family, social, cultural and public life;
- risks of neglect, coercion, restraint, abandonment or exclusion; and
- good practices that promote dignity, autonomy and rights-based care.
The report will not seek to provide an exhaustive analysis of disability rights, dementia, long-term care systems, or elder abuse as separate fields. Rather, it will examine dependency in older age as a cross-cutting human rights issue affecting autonomy, dignity, participation, equality and recognition before the law and in society.
Key questions and types of input/comments sought
The Independent Expert welcomes submissions from States, national human rights institutions, civil society organizations, activists, corporations, academics, healthcare and care professionals, international organizations, as well as older persons, caregivers, families, and all other relevant stakeholders.
Inputs are welcome in relation to particular States or territories, as well as more general inputs concerning populations, regions or the international community as a whole. Respondents are requested to limit their comments to a maximum of 2,500 words. Additional supporting materials, such as reports, academic studies, and other types of background materials may be annexed to the submission.
Following are some illustrative questions to guide inputs, though submissions are welcome to address all or only some of these questions, or other relevant issues that are not identified below.
- How do laws, policies or institutional practices in your country or area of work address situations of dependency in older age?
a. Examples: long-term care, supported living, healthcare, community inclusion, decision-making support. - What are the main risks to the dignity, autonomy, participation and other human rights of older persons living in situations of dependency?
a. Examples: paternalism, infantilization, exclusion from decision-making, neglect, restraints, institutionalization, social invisibility. - How are the preferences, wishes and decision-making capacities of older persons supported in situations of physical frailty, disability, cognitive impairment or reliance on care?
a. Examples: supported decision-making, advance directives, communication support, participation in care planning. - Are there legal, institutional or social practices that may unintentionally undermine the autonomy, dignity or participation of older persons in situations of dependency?
a. Examples: overprotection, automatic substitute decision-making, restrictive care practices, exclusion from social life. - What barriers do older persons in situations of dependency face in remaining included in family, community, cultural and public life?
a. Examples: segregation, institutional isolation, inaccessible environments, stigma, lack of support services. - What safeguards exist to prevent neglect, coercion, abuse, abandonment, inappropriate institutionalization or excessive restriction of autonomy?
a. Examples: legal safeguards, complaints mechanisms, monitoring systems, advocacy services, supported decision-making frameworks. - How are informal caregivers and family members supported while respecting the dignity, autonomy and rights of older persons receiving care?
a. Examples: respite care, caregiver training, shared decision-making, support for home and community care. - What good practices, laws, programmes or community-based approaches have proven effective in preserving dignity, participation and autonomy in situations of dependency?
a. Examples: rights-based care models, dementia-inclusive communities, supported living arrangements, person-centred care. - What recommendations would you make to strengthen a human-rights-based approach to dependency in older age?
a. Examples: legal reforms, care standards, participation mechanisms, safeguards against exclusion or coercion.
How inputs will be used?
We kindly request that your submission be concise and limited to a maximum of 5 pages (or 2,500 words). Submissions can address all or only some of the questions above.
Inputs should be submitted only in English, French, or Spanish.
We appreciate your efforts to submit your valuable inputs for this report, and your collaboration and support for the implementation of this mandate. If there is information that you have previously sent to other special procedures or human rights mechanisms that may be relevant, kindly refer to that information in order to avoid duplication and
facilitate coordination.
Unless specifically requested otherwise and provided they are in line with UN norms and standards, submissions will be posted on the Special Rapporteur’s homepage at the OHCHR website and may be referenced in the reports. In view of consent and privacy issues, contributions containing names of alleged victims will be considered but not
published online.
For additional information on the mandate, please visit the website of the Independent Expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons.