Skip to main content
Report

Call for input – Special Rapporteur on summary, extrajudicial or arbitrary executions – The death penalty from the perspective of the prohibition against torture and other forms of ill-treatment and the protection of human dignity

Issued by

Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions

Published

17 July 2026

presented to

Human Rights Council at its sixty second session

Report

Issued by Special Procedures

Subject

Death penalty

Symbol Number

A/HRC/62/37

Report

Issued by Special Procedures

Subject

Older persons

Symbol Number

A/81/215

Background

The Human Rights Committee’s General Comment No. 36 on article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, pertaining to the right to life,[1.1] concluded that the death penalty is an exceptional regime subject to stringent safeguards and must not be carried out in a manner contrary to article 7 (the absolute prohibition against torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment). It further stated that:
“…Although the allusion to the conditions for application of the death penalty in article 6, paragraph 2, suggests that when drafting the Covenant the States parties did not universally regard the death penalty as a cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment per se, subsequent agreements by the States parties or subsequent practice establishing such agreements, may ultimately lead to the conclusion that the death penalty is contrary to article 7 of the Covenant under all circumstances. 
The increasing number of States parties to the Second Optional Protocol, aiming at the abolition of the death penalty, other international instruments prohibiting the imposition or carrying out of the death penalty, and the growing number of non-abolitionist States that have nonetheless introduced a de facto moratorium on the exercise of the death penalty, suggest that considerable progress may have been made towards establishing an agreement among the States parties to consider the death penalty as a cruel, inhuman or degrading form of punishment. Such a legal development is consistent with the pro-abolitionist sprit of the Covenant, which manifests itself, inter alia, in the texts of article 6, paragraph 6 and the Second Optional Protocol.”
In his 2022 report to the General Assembly,[1.2] the Special Rapporteur examined the question of the death penalty and concluded that: “Beyond the doctrinal analysis of treaties, and beyond the shrinking number of retentionist States clinging on to this lethal sentence as a legitimate form of criminal punishment, the idea that the death penalty does not constitute torture simply lacks persuasion.” He urged the international community to resolve this uncertainty on the basis of evolving international human rights law and medical research with regards to the effects of the death penalty on those sentenced to death and their families. 
Against this background, the present report will examine the pain and suffering inflicted at each stage of the process of capital punishment—investigation and trial, death-row conditions, methods of execution, and post-execution practices—and its impact on the condemned person and their family members, including discriminatory patterns, from the perspective of the absolute prohibition of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, and the protection of human dignity.

Objectives

The objective of the report is to examine the death penalty from the perspective of the prohibition against torture and other forms of ill-treatment under international law and based on medical and legal evidence, through:

  1. Examining the conduct of capital punishment proceedings—investigation, charging, interrogation, trial and sentencing—to determine where practices inflict severe physical or mental pain or suffering, assess compliance with fair-trial guarantees, and understand the impact of these proceedings on both the accused and their families;
  2. Assessing conditions of detention for persons on death row and the cumulative suffering associated with prolonged confinement, including under de jure or de facto moratoria;
  3. Evaluating methods of execution and their protocols against the prohibition of torture or other ill-treatment, including through clinical/forensic assessments, transparency measures, oversight mechanisms and investigation of incidents;
  4. Reviewing post-execution practices, including notification, last visits, handling and return of remains, access to autopsy findings and personal effects, and the treatment and support of family members;
  5. Assessing the impact, including mental and physical consequences, of the death penalty on the families of those sentenced to death, and potentially on other stakeholders involved in carrying out the death penalty;
  6. Analysing discriminatory patterns and their consequences in the imposition and implementation of the death penalty on persons in situations of vulnerability (e.g., disability, indigence/social class, race/ethnicity, literacy, gender, nationality/migration status);
  7. Clarifying the respective obligations of State authorities and the responsibilities of private actors involved in the development, supply or research of execution methods, drugs or devices;
  8. Identifying pathways and good practices that reduce suffering and advance abolition, including amnesties, commutations, systematic sentence reviews and rights-compliant adjustments to death-row detention regimes including during de jure or de facto moratoria; and
  9. Formulating practical, evidence-based recommendations to ensure compliance with international human rights law and to uphold human dignity in relation to the death penalty.
Key questions and types of input/comments sought

The Special Rapporteur welcomes information from States, practitioners and experts, national human rights institutions, academics, civil society organisations, death-penalty survivors, families of persons sentenced to death, and other stakeholders. He particularly welcomes examples of laws, jurisprudence, rules/regulations, data and independent reports on whether the process of implementing the death penalty, from sentencing up to execution, is compatible with the universal and absolute prohibition of torture.

Please address, inter alia, the following:

A. Investigation, charges and interrogation

  • Safeguards against torture and other ill-treatment (e.g., prompt access to counsel and an independent medical examination; audio-visual recording of interviews; exclusion of coerced evidence; prompt judicial control mechanisms and habeas corpus rights).
  • Independent investigation and remedies where abuse is alleged.

B. Proceedings (trial and sentencing)
 

  • Ensuring an effective defence (qualified counsel at all stages; disclosure; adequate time and facilities for a trial; interpreters/experts; meaningful right of appeal).
  • Situations of heightened arbitrariness or suffering (mandatory death penalty; evidentiary presumptions; secrecy or classified evidence; use of unlawfully obtained evidence).

C. Death-row phenomenon and confinement
 

  • Death-row detention regimes (segregation/solitary confinement; visitation; exercise; light/noise exposure; temperature; nutrition; health and mental-health care; access to family; freedom of religion or belief).
  • Duration on death row and clinical and/or judicial findings on cumulative suffering; monitoring and mitigation measures.
  • Moratoria: impact of de jure/de facto moratoria on the length and conditions of detention; adaptations to reduce suffering; access to review or commutation.

D. Methods of execution
 

  • Authorised methods (e.g. lethal injection, hanging, shooting, nitrogen hypoxia/asphyxiation, electrocution) and medical/forensic assessment of pain and suffering.
  • Transparency of protocols (drug sourcing/testing, device calibration, contingency planning, review of individual’s health status and likelihood of suffering pain during execution process), independent monitoring, and post-mortem reviews (autopsy, documentation, public reporting).
  • Records of botched or problematic executions, subsequent investigations, accountability and reforms.

E. Post-execution practices (return of remains to families)
 

  • Notification procedures; last visits; handling and return of remains and personal effects; access to autopsy findings; burial/cremation; information, privacy and psychosocial support for families.

F. Discrimination
 

  • Evidence of discrimination (race/ethnicity, indigence/social class, nationality/migration status, literacy, gender, disability) across stages.
  • Identification and protection of persons with physical, intellectual, or psychosocial disabilities and other vulnerabilities.
  • Harms to families (economic, psychosocial, legal) and available services and remedies

G. Responsibility
 

  • State authorities: oversight; data transparency; complaints and independent investigations; reparation (restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, satisfaction and guarantees of non-repetition).
  • Private actors: roles of companies, universities and health institutions in developing or supplying execution methods, drugs or devices; human rights due diligence; examples of divestment or supply-control measures; research practices and ethics.

H. Good practices and recommendations

  • Good practices alternatives to the death penalty; restrictions on offences for which it is applicable; and measures towards abolition, including amnesties, systematic sentence review and commutation; improved detention conditions; transparency; independent medical oversight; and prohibition of specific methods.
How inputs will be used?

Submissions may be made available on the website of the Special Rapporteur. Should contributors wish that their submissions be kept confidential, please make an explicit request in the submission. 
In line with the Code of Conduct for Special Procedures Mandate-holders of the Human Rights Council and Manual of Operations of the Special Procedures of the Human Rights Council, mandate holders operate based on objective, reliable information and dependable facts. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur reserves the right not to publish submissions that may not meet this threshold, as well as information containing personal information of minors or that could put the submitters or others at risk of reprisals or intimidation.


1.1. Human Rights Committee, General comment No. 36 (2018) on article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, on the right to life, CCPR/C/GC/36 (30 October 2018), para. 51.

1.2. A/77/270, Paragraph 93, page 20

VIEW THIS PAGE IN: